An enormous scale quandary for South Africa

Presidents Cyril Ramaphosa and Vladimir Putin at the first Russia-Africa Summit in Sochi, Russia, in 2019. Photos: GCIS

Presidents Cyril Ramaphosa and Vladimir Putin on the first Russia-Africa Summit in Sochi, Russia, in 2019. Pictures: GCIS

Global Felony Courtroom He issued a global arrest warrant of Russian President Vladimir Putin for conflict crimes associated with the unlawful deportation of kids from Ukraine to Russia. Such movements are regarded as conflict crimes below two articles of the regulation Rome Statutewho established the courtroom.

Arrest warrants from the Global Felony Courtroom v It’s uncommon for heads of state to sit down down.

Putin faces arrest if he steps foot in both 123 signatories for the elemental machine. Of those, 33 are African nations. The problem may just come to a head in August when South Africa prepares to host the fifteenth summit of the Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa (BRICS) bloc in Durban.

As the top of a member state, Putin has been invited to wait. However as a member of the Courtroom, South Africa is sure by way of Article 86 of the ICC Statute and Native regulation For complete cooperation by way of arresting the Russian president.

This isn’t the primary time the rustic has confronted this type of quandary.

2015 Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir visited the rustic to wait a summit Heads of State of the African Union. Relating to South Africa’s duties to the ICC, it was once forced to arrest Al-Bashir, who was once Accused For committing violations of global humanitarian regulation and human rights regulation within the Darfur area of Sudan. The federal government headed by way of Jacob Zuma refused to arrest him. Invoking immunity from prosecution for sitting heads of state below global regulation.

The arrest warrant in opposition to Putin has put President Cyril Ramaphosa’s executive between a rock and a troublesome position. Complying with its home and global duties by way of enforcing the arrest warrant would alienate Russia. This could have twin penalties – the rustic continues to be regarded as a chum by way of the ruling African Nationwide Congress in accordance with the Soviet Union’s enhance all through the combat in opposition to apartheid – in addition to repercussions inside the BRICS, given Moscow’s sturdy ties with Beijing.

It’s not unreasonable to mention that the Ramaphosa executive desires to tread in moderation to steer clear of this sort of tensions.

Learn extra: 5 very important readings on Russian-African members of the family

Alternatively, welcoming Putin like this Emphasis at the unbiased international coverage of South Africawill see the rustic lose its global credibility.

One imaginable impact is that South Africa may just lose its preferential buying and selling phrases. As an example, it would jeopardize its remedy of exports to america below Africa Enlargement and Alternative Act (AGOA). Lately AGOA has been used as a device to punish Ethiopia, Gambia and Mali for “unconstitutional trade of governments” and Gross violations of across the world known human rights“.

Extra necessary , South Africa’s industry with america a ways exceeds that with Russia.


When the Zuma management refused to arrest al-Bashir, it landed the federal government in a judicial limbo. South African Ideal Courtroom of Attraction is located It violated global and home regulation.

After the Ideal Courtroom of Attraction’s determination, Zuma’s executive notified the UN Secretary-Common of its goal to withdraw from the Rome Statute. This unwise transfer was once challenged within the Pretoria Top Courtroom. He. She to rule That the declaration of withdrawal was once unconstitutional within the absence of prior parliamentary approval. Therefore, the federal government “withdraw from withdraw”.

in 2017, Discovered the Global Felony Courtroom That South Africa has failed in its duties below the Rome Statute to the Courtroom to not arrest and extradite Al-Bashir. Alternatively, the courtroom made up our minds to not pursue this situation Sensible causes. It additionally justified it by way of referring South Africa to the United Countries Safety Council for non-compliance “It is going to no longer be a great way to advertise cooperation someday”.

Within the tournament that Putin attended the approaching BRICS summit and the Ramaphosa executive didn’t arrest him, it might imply that South Africa was once violating native regulation in addition to its charter. Article 165 (5) of the rustic charter It displays that the federal government is sure by way of courtroom orders and choices.

Learn extra: Al-Bashir: What does the regulation say concerning the tasks of South Africa?

How must South Africa reply to this quandary?

At the present time the federal government’s reaction isn’t transparent. At the one hand, the spokesperson for Ramaphosa He stated That the state was once acutely aware of its duties to arrest Putin and hand him over to the Global Felony Courtroom.

Alternatively, Exterior Members of the family Minister Naledi Pandor showed Invite Putin to wait the BRICS assembly. She famous that the Council of Ministers must make a decision find out how to reply in gentle of the ICC memorandum.

The federal government would possibly need to in moderation steadiness its duties to the ICC with home obligations and its traditionally pleasant members of the family with Russia. Until it’s excited about difficult courtroom choices and its personal rules, there are alternatives to be had to steer clear of any other spherical of global condemnation, and this must assist it steer clear of possible courtroom battles by way of civil society for non-compliance with the rustic’s rules and courtroom choices.


First, South Africa must proceed to ask Russia to the summit. Alternatively, thru diplomatic channels, they demanded that the Russian delegation be headed by way of its international minister, Sergey Lavrov. Lavrov, in essence, become the face of Russia global theatre Because the starting of the conflict in Ukraine.

Secondly, all through the COVID pandemic, it has develop into transparent that bodily attendance at global gatherings of heads of state may also be changed by way of a digital one. The United Countries Common Meeting has set a just right usual for this for heads of state Video information equipped because of pandemic restrictions. Putin may just attend the BRICS summit just about.

The desire for summit paperwork to be signed by way of Heads of State isn’t an obstacle to bodily attendance. Putin can signal the paperwork electronically or after the summit, if a non-electronic signature is needed.

The ball is now within the South African executive’s courtroom. The hope is that you are going to make the proper determination, one this is in the most productive pursuits of the rustic and its other people – no longer Russia or the likes of america, particularly since neither of the 2 main powers has signed the ICC Statute. Neither of them must inform South Africa what to make a decision.

And most significantly, the federal government must no longer trample by itself rules and courtroom choices. The concern must be adherence to the charter. You make a decision in the most productive pursuits of South Africa and its other people may even supply steerage for the 32 different African signatories to the ICC, must they face a identical quandary someday.

This newsletter was once co-authored by way of Sacha Lee Stephanie Afrika (LLD), a South African Top Courtroom legal professional and previous lecturer at Stellenbosch College and the College of Johannesburg.

This newsletter has been republished from Dialog, a nonprofit information website online devoted to sharing concepts from educational mavens. If you happen to to find it attention-grabbing, you’ll be able to Subscribe to our weekly newsletters.

written by way of: Sasha Dominic (Dove) BachmannAnd College of Canberra.

Learn extra:

Sascha-Dominik (Dov) Bachmann does no longer paintings for, obtain investment from, visit, or personal any corporate or group, and has disclosed no related affiliations following his educational appointment.